Eight Main Facts:
1. All Jewish groups from Yemeni to Polish Jews have simular haplogroup frequency. If we imagine that somehow Ashkenazi Jews are Khazarian converts than their haplogroup distribution couldn't match the haplogroup distribution and frequencies of Moroccon Jews. Both populational groups have mutations and haplogroups which are caracteristical to non Muslim Middle-East (Samaritanians Druze and lebanese Christians) and partialy to Muslim Middle-East.
So all Jewish groups have identical frequencies of identical haplogroups proving that they do represent one ethnic group with comon origin.If the origin of one part of the group is Khazarian than the origin of the rest have to be Khazarian too.However its a historycal non sense to claime that for example Tunesian Jews could have any Khazarian ancestors
2. Samaritanians
Genetic studies of Israelite Samaritanians by Shen 2004, proved that the genetics of Samaritanians clusters with all Jewish groups while are having huge differences with their long time host people ''Palestinian'' Arabs. Ashkenazi Jews are genetically identical in populational distance with Samaritanians as well as Sepharadic Jews (Click here to download Shen2004.PDF) 'Table 3 presents the pair-wise genetic distances (Fst) between 11 populations from AMOVA applied to the Y-chromosomal and mitochondrial data. For the Y-chromosome, all Jewish groups, except for the Ethiopians, are closely related to each other. They do not differ
significantly from Samaritans (0.041) and Druze (0.033), but are different from Palestinians (0.163), Africans (0.219), and Europeans (0.111) (Table 4).
Nevertheless, the data in Tables 3 and 4 indicate that the Samaritan and Jewish Y-chromosomes
have a much greater affinity than do those of the Samaritans and their longtime geographical neighbors, the Palestinians.
3. Jewish haplogroups 50% J,20% E1b1b1c) does not exist among any nation outside Middle East. Isolated populations with high J (South Europeans who mixed with Middle Eastern population) do not have J above 30% while population with high E1b1b1c outside middle east do not have high J
Jewish haplogroups part of genetical landscape of Middle-East:
Click here to view World Haplogroup Frequencies by Population (Ethnic, National, Regional)
4. Religious non sense
From the late I and early second century mass conversions to Judaism are forbiden by Halacaha therfore its videly unimaginable that leter of this time such conversions happened on mass scale
5.Historycal non sense
Jewish comunities existeed in Europe centuries before alleged Khazar conversion. Jews were expelled from France in III century from Germany in V century. According to historians Jews consisted 10-15% of Roman empire population Jews are known to have lived in Greece and Italy in 1st century BCE, Austria Germany 2nd and 3rd century ACE,Turkey north Africa 2nd century BCE, Iraq and Persia 2nd century BCE, central Europe, Germany 2nd century A.CE.
6 Yiddish
Any language have to have caracteristics with common languages.Therfore if Ashkenazi Jews would originate from Khazars Yiddish will for sure have to have some Turcic elements common for the envirviment from where it occured.
However Yiddish which is known to be spoken from VIII century ACE don't have any Turcic elements. Its highly influenced by German Hebrew and Arameic languages but not a simple world is originating from Turcic languages.
7. Culture of Khazars
If A Jews are Khazars they couldn't somehow forget their roots.Some cultural traditional expresions from Khazar people will somehow have to be present in traditions of Ashkenazi Jews which would represent simularities with other Turcic people.However no such tradition or custom exist (folk dance,beleves,rituals etc).
8. Jewish emigration to East Europe -Poland and Russia on mass is well documented from IX century happened from WEST and not from EAST as proved by numerous historians.
Read More:
Origin and Genetic of the Jews
No comments:
Post a Comment